電腦領域 HKEPC Hardware - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: [操作疑難] HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB 好嘈!! ... 有無用家都係咁?? [10 Mar 2015 UPDATE] [打印本頁]

作者: god_snowman 時間: 2015-3-9 18:13 標題: HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB 好嘈!! ... 有無用家都係咁?? [10 Mar 2015 UPDATE]

本帖最後由 god_snowman 於 2015-3-10 23:31 編輯

HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB 係我用過最嘈嘅硬碟...
係IDLE時隔幾秒就'git'一聲仲要好剌耳
買咗2隻 2隻都係咁所以應該唔係個別問題

而家後悔買咗仲要係2隻... (有啲想賣咗去買番隻靜D...

有無用家都係咁???

===10 Mar 2015 Update Below

以下係GOOGLE返黎既資料

1. HGST知道有依個問題但唔知道有冇辦法FIX到 (http://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=1264141 - https://lime-technology.com/forum/index.php?topic=38276.0)
2. 用耐啲會冇咁嘈 (http://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoar ... e_hgst_nas_6tb_yet/ - http://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=1264141)
3. 唔係每隻都係咁嘈 (https://lime-technology.com/forum/index.php?topic=38276.0 - http://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoar ... e_hgst_nas_6tb_yet/ - Amazon D reviews)

上面第2個POINT好似係真今日隻6TB冇昨日咁嘈(但都係嘈) 希望可以更靜啲

作者: pc1668 時間: 2015-3-9 18:22

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2015-3-9 18:24 編輯

HGST is known for noisy drives (might be for particular models). I had a quite noisy 1TB (always click click click) which showed 'very normal' results from all kinds of drive test tools. At the end, of course sold. For instance, I've a non-noisy 2TB which have been used for more than 4 years w/o any problem.

作者: god_snowman 時間: 2015-3-9 18:40

HGST is known for noisy drives (might be for particular models). I had a quite noisy 1TB (always c ...
pc1668 發表於 2015-3-9 18:22

What software do you use to test the drive? THX (Want to test mine

作者: parnhk 時間: 2015-3-9 19:28

我用緊一隻HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB ,比wd red Nas 6T嘈
但速度快個 wd

作者: god_snowman 時間: 2015-3-9 19:55

我用緊一隻HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB ,比wd red Nas 6T嘈
但速度快個 wd
parnhk 發表於 2015-3-9 19:28

HGST真係快
想問WD RED IDLE 和 WRITE 嘈唔嘈? THX

作者: AC360 時間: 2015-3-9 22:54

HGST真係快
想問WD RED IDLE 和 WRITE 嘈唔嘈? THX
god_snowman 發表於 2015-3-9 19:55

WD RED一定會靜d, 因為RED同GREEN一樣轉速只係5千幾轉

不過講嘈, HGST應該都未夠同樣係7200轉既WD RE嘈

作者: god_snowman 時間: 2015-3-9 22:59

WD RED一定會靜d, 因為RED同GREEN一樣轉速只係5千幾轉

不過講嘈, HGST應該都未夠同樣係7200轉既WD RE嘈 ...
AC360 發表於 2015-3-9 22:54

我部機內都有TOSHIBA + SEGATE 3TB
都係7200RPM

係咪6TB密度太高會易嘈@@?

作者: AC360 時間: 2015-3-9 23:02

我部機內都有TOSHIBA + SEGATE 3TB
都係7200RPM

係咪6TB密度太高會易嘈@@?
god_snowman 發表於 2015-3-9 22:59

6T內裡用既碟片數量比3T多

作者: pc1668 時間: 2015-3-10 10:49

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2015-3-10 10:50 編輯

What software do you use to test the drive? THX (Want to test mine
god_snowman 發表於 2015-3-9 18:40

For HGST official software, we can use HGST Windows Drive Fitness Test (WinDFT)
http://www.hgst.com/support/downloads

I also use WD Data Lifeguard Diagnostic for Windows
http://support.wdc.com/product/d ... p;sid=3&lang=en

As long as warranty is concerned, better use OEM software.

作者: zoin0000 時間: 2015-3-10 11:38

WD RED一定會靜d, 因為RED同GREEN一樣轉速只係5千幾轉

不過講嘈, HGST應該都未夠同樣係7200轉既WD RE嘈 ...
AC360 發表於 2015-3-9 22:54

你用過Re未先,HGST明顯比Re同Red嘈好L多,

我4隻Red 行Nas同3隻RE都無一隻HGST嘈

作者: AC360 時間: 2015-3-10 13:34

你用過Re未先,HGST明顯比Re同Red嘈好L多,

我4隻Red 行Nas同3隻RE都無一隻HGST嘈 ...
zoin0000 發表於 2015-3-10 11:38

講得出就肯定用過啦

現在用緊二隻WD RE4行RAID, 明顯聽到有"炒豆聲", 呢個已經係WD RE既標緻黎, 上網一seach就可以搵到大量用戶反映

作者: derekbeckham 時間: 2015-3-10 15:30

我昨天買左2隻HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB...勁嘈...
而家好後悔

作者: pc1668 時間: 2015-3-10 15:46

本帖最後由 pc1668 於 2015-3-10 16:03 編輯

我昨天買左2隻HGST Deskstar NAS 6TB...勁嘈...
而家好後悔
derekbeckham 發表於 2015-3-10 15:30

luckily i did not buy
may be the 4TB version is better (in terms of noise level)

ps. Occasionally, my Toshiba 3TB was also a bit noisy (during read/write operation). Btw, technically Toshiba was also made by HGST (... since the acquisition).

作者: haroball 時間: 2015-3-10 19:58

我用緊4隻HGST 3TB 好靜下
係末6TB多D所以咁???

作者: zoin0000 時間: 2015-3-10 20:19